Column: Who Will Survive Online Shakeout?

May 17, 2009  •  Post A Comment

There’s just not enough money to go around on the Web. That’s why the digital studios are tumbling down.
The first to fall was Mania TV in March, followed by 60 Frames earlier this month. More will surely shutter in the coming months.
The question is, who will be left standing? Digital studios like Deca, Agility, Next New Networks, Electric Farm Entertainment, Revision3 and others are fiercely competing with YouTube, Hulu, broadcast and cable networks and online video advertising networks for the precious few Web video ad dollars. Media firm Magna forecasts the U.S. market for online video will grow by 32% this year, rising from $531 million in 2008 to $699 million in 2009.
That’s just not enough to keep everyone fed.
“Digital studios are obviously challenged,” said Adam Kasper, senior VP and director of digital media at Media Contacts. “They sell high-priced creative services without long-term, contractual relationships with marketers. That means they are pitching all the time. I don’t see that as a sustainable business model. It’s too taxing on an organization.”
For Web video to work for advertisers, brands want to be involved early on in the creative process to meet their marketing objectives, said Jordan Levin, CEO of Generate, a multimedia production shop. Generate creates Web series, but the company also produces for TV and film and manages talent, allowing for multiple revenue streams.
“A pure-play digital studio cannot by definition offer a solution for brands that extends beyond a single digital platform. If a brand’s desire is to reach consumers and engage those consumers, you have to follow consumer behavior,” he said.
Break Media is similarly diversified. Break produces original branded content, but its core business is the distribution network it owns, led by Break.com.
“We license content, but we also have distribution, so we can control our own destiny,” said Break Media CEO Keith Richman. “In an ROI-driven economy, advertisers are focused on getting their ads seen and a media plan that guarantees exposure.”
Still, a number of pure-play digital studios remain, and they say a smart approach to business is their key to long-term success.
My Damn Channel operates a lean business, has never employed more than half a dozen staffers and hasn’t raised much venture money. As a result, it’s very selective about the shows it produces, investing in inexpensive properties with celebrities attached such as Sarah Silverman and Isla Fisher. The company, now profitable, was one of the first digital studios to hit the black.
Next New Networks aims to operate like a cable network, said CEO Lance Podell. “We build brands that are relevant to passionate, underserved communities,” he said. “In our world, [Next New Networks’] ‘Indy Mogul’ is a network, and if one of the shows under Indy Mogul doesn’t attract viewers, then the other shows will and new shows will be developed under the network brand. We now have more than 25 million consistent views of our programming every month.”
Even so, longer-form premium content is going to attract the bulk of the ad dollars for now, said Maria Cirino, a venture capitalist with 406 Ventures.
That’s why any digital studio that survives will need a low-cost, high-revenue model. The Denver-based digital network Jookt covers high school sports and recently shifted its business model to significantly reduce expenses. Last fall the network relied primarily on professional photographers and spent about $70,000 each month to create 20 stories.
Now Jookt is churning out about 100 pieces a month for about $20,000 by relying on high school and college students and less expensive crews, said Jeff Bennis, the company’s CEO.
Maybe what this time of transition really means is everyone in the creative business is going to get paid a lot, lot, lot less.


  1. This is another good column from Daisy, but it overlooks the elephant in the room, namely the very real possibility that NONE of the online video businesses can survive in their present form.
    I think those of us who cover these topics (and I include myself) are guilty of deliberate bias that has gone too far.
    In our enthusiasm for the flexibility and creativity that can be found online, we have given “new media” a free pass to promote a business model that is both flimsy and unsustainable.
    Worse, we promote the notion that traditional television is somehow being killed by the growth of new media. This is completely false, as Fox Chairman Peter Roth made clear in a speech today:
    I applaud Daisy for pointing out the shrinking economics of broadband video. As more businesses succumb, I think a whole lot of producers will discover that there is literally no way to compete with “high school and college” video crews and still make monthly mortgage payments.

  2. All true. But I’m wondering if the “Peter Roth” mention was a Freudian slip!

  3. Digital studios will remain moribund until there is widespread availability of web-to-tv technology and the commensurate programming. In much the same way that the iPod finally made digital music ubiquitous, it will take a Boxee or Tivo or a yet-to-be-unveiled set-top box that can deliver web content in a television viewing experience. You know, lean-back technology as opposed to lean-forward technology.

  4. My company has been developing a site for a few months now and will be releasing it next month as a private beta.
    It’s based on the understanding that the digital video studio model for the most part won’t work based on the traditional status quo approach.

  5. I wonder how long journalists will still be able to write these kinds of stories and get paid for them? 😉

  6. Daisy,
    I enjoy watching your videos and reading your articles but this one is hard to read because of the weird characters all over the article.
    I am guessing you wrote it on a different CMS and the pasted here.
    Thanks and keep up the good work,

  7. This is my first time here and i am likeing your website , and this post is just good, keep it up man

  8. Lindsay Lohan Will Go to Treatment Today,. you’ll find it’s simply a ploy to decrease the jail time hence the judge may be easygoing with her. Soft rehabilitation is sooo much better than jail, could be the judge is not going to give her any jail time on account that he’ll be so happy!

  9. Thanks .. saved me googling for more information.

  10. Nothing better than Yahoo finding us a good website related to what I was looking for.

  11. Know whether the site is opened too late.

  12. Know whether the site is opened too late.

  13. You did the logo. I want to do something like that.

  14. Loved the post, great work! You really play up the details!

  15. This is such a great resource that you are providing and you give it away for free. I love seeing websites that understand the value of providing a quality resource for free. It is the old what goes around comes around routine. Did you acquired lots of links and I see lots of trackbacks??

  16. Thanks for the great work! Cool blog. You will find several opinions on this topic and this blog states the problem extremely good.

  17. Kvepalai moterims

  18. Love all the opinions expressed here! How is everyone? Love how everyone expresses whatr they feel :)

  19. Thank you for great article. I had a very good time reading, and there were few things I was surprised by.

  20. Good Stuff. Thank you. Also check out http://www.kmusikonline.com

  21. Wow, amazing blog layout! How long have you been blogging for? you make blogging look easy.

  22. Hi. First of all – fantastic blog! Secondly this article was also good and interesting to read, but I don’t think everything you have said is how it is in reality. I will need to google about few things you have mentioned in your artcile to make sure. But anyway thanks for trying and good luck on writing other articles. P.S sorry for bad English, I aren’t English native speaker.

  23. Kudos for the great piece of writing. I am glad I have taken the time to read this.

  24. Hello
    Thanks for sharing this useful info. Keep up the good work.

  25. This is such a fantastic resource that you are providing and you give it away for free. I love seeing internet websites that understand the value of providing a quality resource for free. It’s the old what goes around comes around routine. Regards…

  26. Hi! I found your blog on Bing.It’s really comprehensive and it helped me a lot.
    Continue the good work!

  27. Nice blog.

  28. Hello I really like your comments very much. I viewed your blog on Google and I am confident you will receive many visitors.

  29. How long has your site is online, I see you there too late for this wonderful

  30. I’m happy to discover this great blog. THis is absolutely informative. You can check my blog Auto Traffic Monopoly.

  31. I wish I could create as nice blog as yours. You’ve got loads of readers I wish I could produce as great blog site as yours. You have plenty of followers it tends to make sence as your content is really excellent.

  32. Your site is awesome I’m sure you need to translate it to other languages.

  33. You wrote nice post. I like your blog it contains very informative article I will share it with my friends. they also roofers Thanks!
    Vancouver Roofing Company

  34. Kudos for the great article. I am glad I have taken the time to learn this.

  35. I commonly don’t respond on web sites except you have some first-rate comprehensible article.

Your Comment

Email (will not be published)