Here’s What’s up With Olive Garden Flip-Flopping About Whether It Pulled Ads From ‘Letterman’ Over the Palin Flap

Jun 19, 2009  •  Post A Comment

By Chuck Ross

What a day.

 Here’s how it went: First, Politico.com reported that the Olive Garden restaurant chain pulled its ads from “Late Show With David Letterman” in response to Letterman’s jokes about Alaska Gov. Sarah Palin and her family.

Politico.com quoted an email sent from Sherri Bruen, Olive Garden’s guest relations manager, to an unnamed individual saying that “there will be no more Olive Garden ads scheduled for ‘The Late Show’ with David Letterman in this year’s broadcast schedule.” Politico.com wrote that the email cited as a reason Letterman’s “inappropriate comments.”

Furthermore, according to Politico.com, Bruen wrote, “We apologize that Mr. Letterman’s mistake, which was not consistent with our standards and values, left you with a bad impression of Olive Garden.”

Politico.com says that Bruen went on to explain, in her email to the individual who complained, that Olive Garden “screens network television programs wherever possible,” but that “telecasts, such as ‘The Late Show’ with David Letterman, are taped on a daily basis, preventing advertisers from reviewing the content prior to airing.”

Well, that seems plain enough. The reporter on the story for Politico—Andy Barr—then followed standard journalism operating procedure and called Olive Garden to verify the authenticity of the emails Politico.com had in its possession.

He reported in the piece that he spoke to Olive Garden’s manager of media relations, who asked not to be quoted on the record. This person, Barr reports, both confirmed the Bruen emails and “confirmed that the company would be pulling its remaining television spots on the program for the rest of the year when asked that question.”

OK. Again, all of this seems pretty straightforward. And though Barr honored his source’s desire to remain anonymous, a quick check of the Olive Garden Web site lists Mara Frazier as Olive Garden’s manager of media relations. A phone call to her connected us to her voicemail, which said she would not return until Monday, June 22, and if members of the press had questions about anything they should contact Rich Jeffers, who, it turns out, is her boss.

Here’s where things take a turn.

Soon after the story appeared on Politico.com, Jeffers issued the following statement:
“Information reported today by Andy Barr of Politico regarding Olive Garden’s advertising on the Late Show with David Letterman was erroneous. No authorized spokesperson for the company confirmed the information in his report.

The Olive Garden media schedule is planned months in advance. The schedule for the Late Show with David Letterman was completed earlier this month. We take all guest concerns seriously. And, as always, we will factor those concerns in as we plan our advertising schedule in the future.”

In a follow-up story, Barr reported that he asked about the earlier confirmation he had received from the Olive Garden’s manager of media relations. Barr wrote that Jeffers replied with this email:

“The so called ‘confirmation’ didn’t come from an authorized spokesperson for the company. The guest email you received did not say the ads were pulled. And as our statement says, the schedule—which is set months in advance—was completed earlier this month.”

Hold on a minute. What the hell’s going on here? The “so-called” confirmation? The manager of media relations, whose job it is to speak to the press, all of a sudden is not authorized to speak for the company?

Having been around as a reporter almost as long as that 11th century village in Tuscany where the Olive Garden (circa 1982) has its Culinary Institute, I think I have a pretty good guess as to what happened.

The company that owns Olive Garden is Darden Restaurants. According to its Web site, it’s the “largest full-service restaurant company in the world.” Besides Olive Garden it owns Red Lobster and The Capital Grille, among others. Darden has more than 1,700 restaurants, posts about $7 billion in annual sales and employs 180,000 workers.

 Like most big companies, it abhors controversy. Controversy is not a win-win. Much better is keeping as many people happy with your product and/or services as possible, so they will keep buying them.

Palin/Letterman is a genuine controversy. It’s not an issue with which the vast majority of marketers want to take sides. And if Letterman’s apology was good enough for Palin, most marketers feel that should be the end of it.

So here’s what we know about Olive Garden in this instance. We know that it had a commercial appear during the June 8 Letterman show. That’s the program during which Letterman first made his Palin jokes.

We know that in response to a complaint about Olive Garden advertising on that program that Sherri Bruen, Olive Garden’s guest relations manager, wrote the emails cited in the Politico.com story.

We also know that Barr, the Politico.com reporter, did exactly what he was supposed to do, and contacted the manager of media relations at Olive Garden, who we assume was Mara Frazier.

 As has happened for time immemorial between reporters and their contacts/sources, she confirmed certain facts to Barr, but asked that he not quote her. Since she works at Darden’s corporate headquarters, and holds the title of manager of media relations, it was fair for Barr to believe that he was speaking to someone who had knowledge of the situation.

Furthermore, it seems clear that she didn’t tell Barr, “No, I don’t know that information,” and that he just made up the confirmation, because Jeffers later says in his statement only that the person Barr spoke with was not an “authorized spokesperson for the company.”

Clearly, after the Politico.com story hit the Internet and started to be picked up by various media outlets—including TVWeek.com—Darden found itself embroiled in a controversy. And that’s not a good thing.

 How convenient, then, to come back and say that the person whose job it is to speak to the media isn’t really supposed to speak to the media, and that the commercial schedule on Letterman was previously scheduled to end on June 8. I’m not saying it’s not true. All I’m pointing out is how convenient it is.

In other words, folks, Olive Garden is saying, poor us, we had the bad luck of advertising on the show when Letterman made some very insensitive jokes, and it was just a coincidence and you can’t blame us for that and listen, whether you love Dave or hate him, and whether you love Palin or hate her, can you please pass the Lasagna Rollatini with Sausage and do you want that with the bottle of Kendall Jackson or Sutter Home?

 Of course Jeffers statement begs the question of how Olive Garden/Darden really feels about the Letterman/Palin issue.

So TVWeek.com got Jeffers on the phone and asked him point blank, “If your ad schedule didn’t happen to end on June 8, would the company have pulled its ads from Letterman’s show for a certain length of time?”

To which Jeffers replied, “That’s a hypothetical, and we don’t answer hypotheticals.”#

Soon after the story appeared on Politico.com, Jeffers issued the following statement:
“Information reported today by Andy Barr of Politico regarding Olive Garden’s advertising on the Late Show with David Letterman was erroneous. No authorized spokesperson for the company confirmed the information in his report.

The Olive Garden media schedule is planned months in advance. The schedule for the Late Show with David Letterman was completed earlier this month. We take all guest concerns seriously. And, as always, we will factor those concerns in as we plan our advertising schedule in the future.”

In a follow-up story, Barr reported that he asked about the earlier confirmation he had received from the Olive Garden’s manager of media relations. Barr wrote that Jeffers replied with this email:

“The so called ‘confirmation’ didn’t come from an authorized spokesperson for the company. The guest email you received did not say the ads were pulled. And as our statement says, the schedule—which is set months in advance—was completed earlier this month.”

Hold on a minute. What the hell’s going on here? The “so-called” confirmation? The manager of media relations, whose job it is to speak to the press, all of a sudden is not authorized to speak for the company?

Having been around as a reporter almost as long as that 11th century village in Tuscany where the Olive Garden (circa 1982) has its Culinary Institute, I think I have a pretty good guess as to what happened.

The company that owns Olive Garden is Darden Restaurants. According to its Web site, it’s the “largest full-service restaurant company in the world.” Besides Olive Garden it owns Red Lobster and The Capital Grille, among others. Darden has more than 1,700 restaurants, posts about $7 billion in annual sales and employs 180,000 workers.

 Like most big companies, it abhors controversy. Controversy is not a win-win. Much better is keeping as many people happy with your product and/or services as possible, so they will keep buying them.

Palin/Letterman is a genuine controversy. It’s not an issue with which the vast majority of marketers want to take sides. And if Letterman’s apology was good enough for Palin, most marketers feel that should be the end of it.

So here’s what we know about Olive Garden in this instance. We know that it had a commercial appear during the June 8 Letterman show. That’s the program during which Letterman first made his Palin jokes.

We know that in response to a complaint about Olive Garden advertising on that program that Sherri Bruen, Olive Garden’s guest relations manager, wrote the emails cited in the Politico.com story.

We also know that Barr, the Politico.com reporter, did exactly what he was supposed to do, and contacted the manager of media relations at Olive Garden, who we assume was Mara Frazier.

 As has happened for time immemorial between reporters and their contacts/sources, she confirmed certain facts to Barr, but asked that he not quote her. Since she works at Darden’s corporate headquarters, and holds the title of manager of media relations, it was fair for Barr to believe that he was speaking to someone who had knowledge of the situation.

Furthermore, it seems clear that she didn’t tell Barr, “No, I don’t know that information,” and that he just made up the confirmation, because Jeffers later says in his statement only that the person Barr spoke with was not an “authorized spokesperson for the company.”

Clearly, after the Politico.com story hit the Internet and started to be picked up by various media outlets—including TVWeek.com—Darden found itself embroiled in a controversy. And that’s not a good thing.

 How convenient, then, to come back and say that the person whose job it is to speak to the media isn’t really supposed to speak to the media, and that the commercial schedule on Letterman was previously scheduled to end on June 8. I’m not saying it’s not true. All I’m pointing out is how convenient it is.

In other words, folks, Olive Garden is saying, poor us, we had the bad luck of advertising on the show when Letterman made some very insensitive jokes, and it was just a coincidence and you can’t blame us for that and listen, whether you love Dave or hate him, and whether you love Palin or hate her, can you please pass the Lasagna Rollatini with Sausage and do you want that with the bottle of Kendall Jackson or Sutter Home?

 Of course Jeffers statement begs the question of how Olive Garden/Darden really feels about the Letterman/Palin issue.

So TVWeek.com got Jeffers on the phone and asked him point blank, “If your ad schedule didn’t happen to end on June 8, would the company have pulled its ads from Letterman’s show for a certain length of time?”

To which Jeffers replied, “That’s a hypothetical, and we don’t answer hypotheticals.”#

43 Comments

  1. This is the DUMBEST thing I have read all month! We don’t even have Olive Garden in Alaska. NOT EVEN ONE!!! What the hell do they care about Governor Palin or the State of Alaska!? They are show boating. Nothing more. And on behalf of all Alaskans I invite Olive Garden to just stay the hell away.

  2. They want it both ways, obviously. Good job tracking the story. I personally believe that the “decision” hurt them either way, where it counts most, in revenue. I will conscientiously avoid Olive Garden, Red Lobster and its other restaurants under the Darden ownership. Besides there are so many better options than to give money to a franchise that sucks the money out of a locality. Corporate battle lost, maybe a turning point in also losing the war.

  3. Sure, the company does not wnt to get in the middle of this, but once you are, you have a moral duty to do what is right, not flip flop like a greedy beast. That list of eateries is a large block of not eating there.

  4. I`m done with olive garden. COWARDS.

  5. Olive Garden is being opportunistic, just like Sarah Palin. They did this to appear as if they were ethical stand and now they are hoping Letterman will joke about them, giving them free publicity.

  6. They probably reversed their reason after seeing that only 15 nuts showed up for the protest.

  7. “Olive Garden is being opportunistic, just like Sarah Palin.”
    Yeah, when she brought her 14-year-old daughter to that baseball game, Letterman fell right into her trap.

  8. Me thinks our President Obama and the mainstream liberal media are in luv with one another. I suggest they all hook up and get a room together. As Bob Dylan sang a few years ago…THINGS HAVE CHANGED

  9. Just one comment. Your article keeps referring to the fact that Letterman’s inappropriate comments were about Palin. They were about her 14 year old daughter.

  10. AAAAAAAAAAARGGGGHH They were meant about her 18-year-old daughter!!!!! THAT’S WHAT HE MEANT. how many times does he have to explain this?

  11. If Olive Garden said Letterman fell below its standards, they owe Dave a BIG apology. I cannot imagine a bigger insult than falling below the standards of sauce-smothered cardboard.

  12. Once and for all, she DID NOT bring ANY daughter to the game, and if you carefully examine her and Todd’s comments, even they didn’t claim that she did–just that she came to NY with Sarah.

  13. That’s NOT what he sang, and the lyrics you perverted are several decades old, not a few years. Do you even know who Bob Dylan is?

  14. If Olive Garden can’t make up their mind about advertising, how are we supposed to trust them to cook their food correctly. I think it is best we all avoid Olive Garden while they think about what they want to be when they grow up!

  15. and that’s why I and my wife haven’t patronized darden for years.

  16. The only bad impression Olive Garden leaves you, is after you ate there

  17. Curious to learn much more about the similar. Can you share additional data?

  18. Thank God we have a common interest, thank you for sharing, you’re a good author. Hope to see more of your articles. Juno sincere.

  19. I like this sport. You like it? what you think of it? If you have some time, it may wish to continue your article to share with you the happiness.

  20. Sorry for the huge review, but I’m really loving the new Zune, and hope this, as well as the excellent reviews some other people have written, will help you decide if it’s the right choice for you.

  21. I come and read constantly. very nice blog

  22. You did the logo. I want to do something like that.

  23. Amazing site, where did you come up with the information in this post? I’m pleased I found it though, ill be checking back soon to see what other articles you have.

  24. Interesting bing brought me to the blog so I was happy to read a good post for a change.

  25. I added Google Reader to your site when I have spare time try to follow.

  26. This is such a great resource that you are providing and you give it away for free. I love seeing websites that understand the value of providing a quality resource for free. It is the old what goes around comes around routine. Did you acquired lots of links and I see lots of trackbacks??

  27. I added Google Reader to your site when I have spare time try to follow.Thank you.

  28. I added Google Reader to your site when I have spare time try to follow.

  29. Where is link?

  30. I added Google Reader to your site when I have spare time try to follow.Thank you.

  31. En güzel erotik filmler burada.

  32. En güzel erotik filmler burada.

  33. Apple now has Rhapsody as an app, which is a great start, but it is currently hampered by the inability to store locally on your iPod, and has a dismal 64kbps bit rate. If this changes, then it will somewhat negate this advantage for the Zune, but the 10 songs per month will still be a big plus in Zune Pass’ favor.

  34. I really liked your article write more..i may add you to their own favorite

  35. many thanks for the sensible analyze. Me & my neighbour were preparing to accomplish some research about which. We got a beneficial book on that make a difference from our local library many books where not because influensive as your tips.

  36. Thank you for great article. I had a very good time reading, and there were few things I was surprised by.

  37. I had a great time reading around your post as I read it extensively. Excellent writing! I am looking forward to hearing more from you

  38. Kudos to you! This is a really good blog here and I love your style of writing. How did you get so good at blogging?

  39. I wish I could create as nice blog as yours. You have lots of admirers I wish I could create as good blog page as yours. You’ve lots of followers it tends to make sence as your content material is very good.

  40. Hey how are you doing? I just wanted to stop by and say that it’s been a pleasure reading your blog. I have bookmarked your website so that I can come back & read more in the future as well. plz do keep up the quality writing

  41. Excellent blog, pls contiune your work and keep us update with fresh articles

  42. Hands down, Apple’s app store wins by a mile. It’s a huge selection of all sorts of apps vs a rather sad selection of a handful for Zune. Microsoft has plans, especially in the realm of games, but I’m not sure I’d want to bet on the future if this aspect is important to you. The iPod is a much better choice in that case.

  43. Thanks for the interesting post. I will be taking advantage of the amazing information on the website. I will be coming back!

Your Comment

Email (will not be published)