A contestant on Fox’s "The Sexiest Bachelor in America" in 2000 was charged with allegedly murdering his girlfriend, a former adult-movie actress, reports the Associated Press.

Brian Lee Randone, now a self-proclaimed preacher, was arrested Sept. 11 and charged last week with one count of torture and one count of murder in the death of his live-in girlfriend Felicia Lee in Monrovia, outside of Los Angeles.

–Elizabeth Jensen