The Critics Poll list of worst shows is typically topped by a tawdry reality program such as Fox’s “The Swan” or an obnoxious sitcom like Fox’s “The War at Home.”
But this summer’s worst shows include several dramas—and the most-disliked program isn’t even on Fox.
ABC’s spring launch of “October Road” benefited from its “Grey’s Anatomy” lead-in and garnered a renewal for next season, but the drama also earned the wrath of critics, who went to bed on Thursday nights with hearts full of hate.
“There’s not an original thought, line of dialogue or image in this painfully derivative, endlessly pandering migraine of a show,” unleashed Matt Roush, TV Guide. “The fact that viewers of ABC’s Thursday lineup were willing to settle for this turgid bonbon of recycled angst was the most depressing development of the spring.”
Fox did make an appearance at No. 2 on the list, with the surprise inclusion of “24.” Last summer the action-drama was ranked No. 4 on the list of best shows. To be fair, many critics bashed this season of the program for failing to live up to its own high standards.
“Soap-opera elements and bad dialogue have always infected this series, but usually the action moves fast enough that you don’t care about the flaws,” wrote Robert Philpot, Fort Worth Star-Telegram. “Not this year. And who decided it was a good idea to both neuter Chloe and make her pregnant?”
Agreed Ken Tucker, Entertainment Weekly: “What a difference a season makes. From an early top-10 slot to its lamest season yet, filled with false turns and mean-mindedness.”
Two NBC shows came in third and fourth: the short-lived reality show “Real Wedding Crashers” and the crime drama “The Black Donnellys,” respectively.
“As if watching a lovingly lit hunk in skivvies bludgeon a dead body to fit into a trash can counts as human drama,” wrote John Griffiths, US Weekly, of “Donnellys.”
The CW’s “Pussycat Dolls Present: The Search for the Next Doll” and TBS’ “Tyler Perry’s House of Payne” were next on the list, but critics had few standout comments until No. 7: the ever-controversial “Nancy Grace” on CNN’s Headline News.
“She represents every bad part of our media culture. She—and CNN—have shown they’re willing to do anything to anyone for ratings,” wrote Rick Kushman, Sacramento Bee.
Charlie McCollum of the San Jose Mercury News wrote that he worries Ms. Grace’s influence will grow: “My deepest fear is that Grace, the Lord High Executioner of TV, will end up as a panelist on ‘The View.’”
- Best Series: A Blaze of Glory for ‘The Sopranos’
- Non-Series: ‘Planet Earth’ Rules But Critics Bury ‘Heart’
- Critics Evaluate Networks’ Fall Pilots
- Critics Poll Results: Series
- Critics Poll Results: Movie, Miniseries or Special